Dear Rungie,
I will do my best to demonstrate the difference.
Here is the RGU course:
Underpinning operations modules:
Energy Marketing (primarily B2B marketing within Oil and Gas)
Strategic Operations Management Oil and Gas
Oil and Gas Management
Underpinning finance and economics modules:
OIl and Gas Economics
Financial and Management Accounting
Corporate Finance
Strategy and Change Modules
People Management & Organisational Development
Strategic Management Environment (a strategic analysis of the Oil and Gas industry and others)
Strategic Management (the 2nd part of strategy looking at how to think about strategy, select and deploying strategy in approprate context supported with industry expertise)
Leadership, Communication and Change
Oil and Gas elective choices that allow for tailoring of your career:
Project Fundamentals
Energy Policy and the Environment
Oil and Gas Contract Law
Health, Safety and Risk in an Organisational Context
Consultancy Project Module within a Company. We find you a company on the full-time study mode through our extensive network and contacts here in Aberdeen.
If you undertake the Distance Learning version you have two additional electives taught by Curtin University
Oil and Gas Markets
Natural Resource Economics (very specific to Australian Market and around).
The entire programme is focused on upstream activities within the Oil and Gas industry. We also have considerable additionality with guest speakers, employability events and workshops and industry engagement and a three week induction. The big question is how to you make management decisions in upstream environment, turn this into strategy and make the strategy a reality.
The Dundee University programme, which is a good programme, is more focused on downstream activity, natural resources (i.e. minerals), law and policy and wider energy mix. Here is their curriculum:
Induction Programme
Finance and Economics modules:
Foundation Financial Accounting
Introduction to Finance
Petroleum Policy and Economics
Law and policy modules pick two:
Downstream Energy Law and Policy
International Petroleum Law and Policy
Mineral and Petroleum Taxation
Management and strategy modules:
Management in Energy and Natural Resources Industries
Strategic Management & Organisational Analysis
Elective choices pick three:
Business Strategy in the Extractive Industries
Environmental Law and Policy for Natural Resources and Energy
Financial and Project Analysis of Natural Resources and Energy Ventures
Human Resources Management
International Law of Natural Resources and Energy
Leadership and Decision Making
Marketing
Project Management Process
Stakeholder Management and Business Ethics
Transnational Investment Law and Policy
You can do a 20 credit or 40 credit internship instead of 1 or 2 of these electives above. You need to find your own internship for the 20 credit version. It is unclear from the website if you need to do this for the 40 credit version.
If you are working in the upstream activity as you are and you intend to manage in this area then the RGU degree is probably more suited for you. If you are moving into a broader energy environment with a slant toward policy and law then Dundee would suit you.
It took me a little time to put this together but I hope it is worthwhile for you. I have tried to be balanced as I can but I am inevitably biased toward my own programme and I can only apologise for this.
Regards,
Allan Scott
MBA Director
www.rgu.ac.uk/mba